Shotokan Karate Magazine Issue 145
Featuring JOHN CHEETHAM
TELLING IT LIKE IT IS
Shotokan Karate Magazine Issue 145
JOHN CHEETHAM. SKM EDITOR. Interview By Graeme Armitage.
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.
MY LEGS DON’T HIT ANYMORE. By Dr Guillermo Laich, M.D., PhD.
A NEW HIP AND AN OLD ROUTINE. By Peter Consterdine.
NEVER THE TWAIN SHALL MEET. By Paul Mitchell.
INFORMATION ON MAKOTO SHINKIN GIMA. By Robert Sidoli & Ryozo Fujiwara.
REFLECTIONS ON CREATING A KATA. By Martin Hurley.
KIME AND KI. By Dr. Wolf Herbert.
This Magazine is available to buy as a printed back issue
EDITORIAL By John Cheetham.
I haven’t done an interview in the magazine since Issue 80 (2004). I have however written dozens of articles so you probably all know where I’m coming from – a bit of a Luddite, old-school. I still love the physical thrill of karate movement, the techniques, the kata, the kumite, the philosophy, at least Funakoshi’s version. What I don’t love anymore, is the emphasis and prominence of Karate as a ‘Sport’.
I recently re-read an interview we did with Ohshima Sensei, in Issue 85. A direct student of Gichin Funakoshi. He’s 90yrs old now. There are no modern-day Sensei with this sagacity, none I’ve met. There are Instructors Yes! But it’s more than just technique. To understand Karate-do and Budo, you should read this interview.
Well, finally after a 31yr hiatus and after several offers of an up-grade from various Shotokan Associations, I’ve now accepted promotion to 5th Dan from an International Shotokan group who I respect highly for their integrity and honesty. I requested that I have no political involvement, affiliation or membership, so there is no need for letters after name and rank. This was kindly granted to me, which I appreciated.
One of the main reasons I decided 36 years ago to dedicate a magazine to Shotokan Karate-do, was because of my admiration and respect for the philosophy (The ‘Do’), The ‘Way’ of Karate, of SHOTO, the founder, Master Gichin Funakoshi. He was a humble man, an educator who never sought fame or riches. Godan (5th Dan) was the highest grade he ever awarded. Funakoshi deemed anything above were just numbers, which is why personally, I am totally satisfied with this final level.
Now, about this issue of SKM....It’s quite difficult to get hold of really good historical material for the magazine. So, I want to say a big thank you to Rob Sidoli for this great look back at the life of Makoto ‘Shinkin’ Gima 1896-1989. An early student of Master Gichin Funakoshi. In March 1923, Master Funakoshi promoted Makoto Gima to shodan. There’s even a photograph of the Dan grade certificate awarded by Master Funakoshi. During Gima’s life he observed the formation of both the Shoto-Kai, and the Japan Karate Association.
If you’ve studied Shotokan Karate-do for a while you will probably have figured out by now that to make sense of Shotokan’s Kata applications you have to look closely at the Jiu Jitsu model, e.g. arm-locks, chokes, grappling techniques.
All well and good – if kept in perspective! However, for all you 45/50 year old’s out there, take heed; because unless you are genetically blessed, if you are still training when you reach 75/80, grappling will be the last thing on your mind Karate-wise! You will more than likely have some osteoarthritis in one of the major joints; likely from the ageing process or over-training. Applying an arm-lock could be more painful for you than the attacker! Knees won’t favour ground-work! Maintaining body speed from A to B through relaxation, and striking accuracy to vital areas will be more important. ‘Karate for health’ will seem more appropriate as a form of self-defence. So, look after your body you 45/50yr old people: You’ll find out in 25/30 years why this is so important. Unless you’re lucky; genetically ‘blessed’!
Good Health, Good Training. Editor.
KIME AND KI. By Dr. Wolf Herbert.
Allow me to add some remarks to the endless discussion about kime (“focus”), thus also proving that the term “endless” is pertinent. I want to put the focus (no pun intended) on an aspect that seems to me to have been underemphasized. My musings are sandwiched between two articles penned by the editor John Cheetham in the Shotokan Karate Magazine issues No. 141 and 142. One may forgive me therefore for repeating some salient quotes for those who do not have them at hand. John Cheetham writes that Nakayama Masatoshi never used the term “kime” in his first book. I leafed through the Japanese original (1965) and found that he does not in fact use “kime” as a noun anywhere, however as a verb (kimeru) it appears on p. 116. It corresponds to the following passage in his book Dynamic Karate (1966, p. 102). My literal translation from the Japanese original would be: “Generally ‘waza (technique) o kimeru’ means to let a well-controlled power explode instantaneously on a chosen target.” In the English version (where there is no mention of kime or kimeru) the translation reads: “Remember that an effective technique in karate is produced by a concentrated blast of power at the moment of impact.”
Nakayama repeatedly writes about “kimewaza” in the sense of “decisive technique”, however not of “kime” as an isolated notion. It almost seems that kime as a word/noun and concept has been taken out of its context and reduced to its physical/muscular aspect.
The word “kime” however, is explicitly used by Nishiyama Hidetaka in his book Karate. The art of empty hand fighting (1960, p. 21) and he calls it “focus”:
“Briefly, ‘focus’ in karate refers to the concentration of all the energy of the body in an instant on a specific target.” This definition notably resembles the one we have seen in Nakayama’s use of it as a verb. Nakayama and Nishiyama obviously shared the same idea about kime and its application. John Cheetham quotes further from Nishiyama’s book: “As the fist nears the target its speed is increased to its maximum point, and at the moment of impact the muscles of the entire body are tensed. ... This, in essence, is what ‘focus’ in karate means.” (end of quote). Now if you read on, you find the following:
“It should not be forgotten that this maximum exertion of energy is instantaneous and in the next instant is withdrawn in preparation for the next movement, i.e., the muscles are relaxed, the breath inhaled, and a position appropriate for the next technique assumed.”
I would argue that exactly this (relax!) was forgotten by many practitioners (and teachers!) back in the early days of Shotokan in the West. “More kime, more kime!” was the battlecry or mantra of the day and lead to hypertensed, stiff and awkward Karate-moves.
We all know the term waza no kankyu as being one of the principles that should be observed when executing a Kata. It relates to the slowness and quickness of technique. The term kankyu is written with two characters, of which the first means: “to loosen, relax” and the second: “swift, rapid”. Nakayama Takatsugu, a karateka and physiotherapist, gives this an interesting interpretation in regard to “kime”. He describes “kime” as a flow from “loose” (kan) to “rapid” (kyu) to “loose” (kan). The body goes from very loose to strong for an instant, only to loosen up again. It is a snapping move like the one of a spring, which is squeezed, then releases its power and immediately returns to its original state. The bigger the amplitude is between relaxation and tension, the bigger the power unleashed. It can also be likened to a wave hitting the shore and pulling back.
This reminds me of muchimi, one of the Okinawan principles, which define a powerful technique. Kime is not emphasized in Okinawan styles. It really seems to be an invention by Nakayama and Nishiyama based on the assumption that tension as such produces power, a (mis)conception imported from Western sports science. Muchimi is interpreted in two ways: Mi can either stand for “body” or differently written for “taste” (metaphorically: “feeling, quality”). “Muchi” is the Okinawan pronunciation of the Japanese “mochi”. This is a sticky, glutinous cake made of pounded steamed rice. In this sense muchimi describes a tough, but supple body and also technically to stick flexibly to your opponent in an altercation. One more meaning derives from the Japanese word “muchi” (whip), thus implying one should use ones body like a whip. A whip lashed out causes as much damage by its initial impact as it does by the laceration due to the pullback movement.
Now the whip-hip or double-hip, which has been revived in Shotokan by Naka Tatsuya sensei, is applied mostly and widely in short range techniques in Okinawan Karate. Kagi-tsuki in Tekki shodan can serve as a good example. Excuted in “whip-hip style” means, that a slight pulling back of the hips before the punch, initiates relaxation, and is followed by the speed of the thrust and throwing in of the hips in the direction of the tsuki. On impact the hip snaps back and again a full body relaxation is achieved. This is the perfect cycle between relaxation – momentary tension – relaxation.
This corresponds to John Cheetham’s Bow & Arrow Analogy article SKM 142. The interesting points are the start (relaxation), the target/impact/“end” and even more so: what happens after the “end”: the implosion or total relaxation. This is known in Taijiquan as “opening/releasing” and “closing/receiving”. “Opening” means that the Ki (“internal/vital energy”) is sent out into the extremities of the body and beyond while executing a technique (an attack). When “closing” one lets the Ki flow back and accumulate again in the lower abdomen. This is harmonized with breathing, exhalation when “opening” and inhalation during “closing”. While the Ki-flow is mentally guided in Taijiquan and the movements are soft and of uniform tempo (andante) in an uninterrupted flow, in Karate they are swift, forceful, abruptly stopped and explosive. The velocity with which the Ki is transported is different, but the effect is the same in the end. From a health-exercise view the flow of the Ki is harmonized, and blockages are removed. Ki is virtually sent through the whole body from head to toe, thus one feels refreshed after a good Karate training session, even if one is physically exhausted.
Kanazawa Hirokazu makes a connection between kime and ki in his autobiography Karate – My life (2003, p. 266):
“There are three kinds of ki which manifest in the tanden, or lower abdomen, which serves as the central powerhouse of our bodies. Tai-ki is the energy drawn from the atmosphere, chi-ki from the ground, and nai-ki resides within the body. This flows through our spine and explodes out of our fists, and this instant is termed kime, or focus.”
It may be noted that kime (or “kimeru” as a verb) can actually be written with two different characters. The one denoting “to decide, determine” is often used and well known. The other character means: “to go to the end, to go to extremes, the apex”. In the Japanese original Kanazawa prefers the latter for “climax” rather than the former in the sense of “decisive point”. One more linguistic remark: the ki in kime (it is just the first syllable) has nothing to do with the ki in the Chinese meaning of “universal energy”, which is a word in itself and written with a completely different character. The term “ki” has an esoteric tang in the West, but it can be understood quite rationally. Allow me to give a brief explanation. I shall concentrate on the aspect called nai-ki by Kanazawa:
Qi (Chn.)/ki (Jpn.) is a psychosomatic holistic concept. In Western anatomy one tends to dissect and separate everything according to function, whereas in eastern thinking the interconnection and homeostasis of the whole body/mind/spirit is central. A mind/matter or soul/body-dualism is not dominant. Thus ki has material and immaterial aspects. It is and flows in the bones, the marrow, the muscles, the blood and circulatory system, the lymphatic and the nervous sysem, the organs, glands, spine and brain and the meridians which connect everything. Ki pervades the totality of physical functions and the mind, which is the conductor in this orchestra. Ki is the regulator or monitor of a fluid balance and the harmonious interplay of all the above mentioned elements.
It has to be stated that Qi/ki has historically never been defined consistently. The concept changed over the centuries from a cosmological/metaphysical one to a more “anthropological” and recently, even a materialistic one. There is a lot of research conducted in the West and in China (under the influence of Western science) to pinpoint what ki might be, or even to find methods to measure it. Research into bioelectromagnetic fields has shown some correlation with the nervous system and mental states. Others concentrate on mitochondrial function and heart rate variability. But these attempts can only highlight and pick out aspects of ki rather than “measure” it in its totality. No single instrument might ever be able to gauge it, not least because of its immaterial aspects. Because ki acts as a psychosomatic regulatory feedback system it is so encompassing, its definition is pliable and can easily be recalibrated or adapted to beliefs or research interests. We can nevertheless operate with ki as a phenomenon, a sensation or hypothesis, empirically corroborated by a legion of practitioners of Traditional Chinese Medicine and martial arts throughout the ages.
Health in the Chinese understanding means that ki can flow freely and without blockages or occlusions. Latter occurrences lead to sickness and indisposition. Acupuncture, moxibustion, massages, gymnastics and meditation (visualisation) were developed from time immemorial to guarantee an unimpeded ki-flow. The martial arts were practiced in this context. Good martial art practice is said to open the energy channels, eliminate blockages and harmonize the flow of ki. Ki can be mobilized, directed and circulated by conscious mental activity. The standard formulas are: “Where the thinking/mind (Jpn. i, Chn. yi) is, there is ki.” “Guiding the ki with the thinking/mind”. Another term widely used in internal martial arts (e.g. Taijiquan, Qigong) is inen. As so often, the characters in this term have various meanings and can hardly be translated by just one word: I means “mind, heart, thought, idea, intention, care”; nen means “idea, feeling, concern, attention, caution” and in a Buddhist context nen is used as the translation of the Sanskrit term smriti (Pali: sati), which means “mindfulness”. Nowadays, this defines a whole method of meditation. Inen thus signifies “consciousness, intention, attentiveness”. “Inen guides the ki” implies, that every mindful physical exercise leads the ki to flow into the parts of the body, on which one concentrates. Thus if one concentrates on the fist, when one focuses (kime) a punch, this will stimulate a surge of ki.
John Cheetham wrote: “Some people say that kime is like putting the brakes on, which makes the energy stay ‘inside the body’ and not transfer to the target.”
If you understand kime in the context of ki, the exact opposite is the case!
Kanazawa Hirokazu was able to split the very board that was indicated to him in a stack of four or five without breaking the rest. His explanation was that he could consciously control and direct his ki. He describes it in his autobiography, which I have translated into German. During the translation process, I spoke to him directly about this, because it has always intrigued me. He told me that everything is connected on a molecular level in the sense that everything is vibrating energy in the end. He described it as visualizing the indicated board vividly and projecting his consciousness into it, becoming one with it, and thus being able to pulverize it. He added with a laugh: “People usually wanted me to break the second or third board, hardly the last one and never the first one. But to stop the ki at the first board and not break the others would have been the hardest task to fulfill.” Kanazawa also used to say that a punch does not end at the fist, but goes way beyond, because the ki shoots out far on and yonder. It is quite clear that ki in this context is connected to a strong mental focus rather than a mere somatic one.
As an aside: when we look at other Southeast Asian martial arts, namely many soft Kung Fu styles, Pentjak Silat or Kalaripayattu, they are very fluid and do not apply kime. Even in Shotokan, its first offspring, the Shotokai, headed by Egami Shigeru, who deemed himself to be totally loyal to Funakoshi Gichin and his Karate, suppleness and relaxation are emphasized.
Kata in Shotokai are performed in a continuous flow, almost tensionless. The fixation on kime in the sense of a physical tightening up of the body seems to be the exception rather than the rule in the wide world of bare hand fighting arts. Therefore it is worth revisiting.
John Cheetham wrote in SKM Issue 141: “30/40 years ago, kime to me was a totally muscular concept, now it’s changed: now a ‘decisive’ blow is a combination of power generated from relaxation, speed, breath, intention and mental focus!” This is a wonderful, comprehensive definition! As we have seen, intention and mental focus are exactly the elements, which mobilize ki. I say this with tongue in cheek: but when the Japanese instructors back in the days exhorted us to put more kime into our techniques, they might just have meant that we concentrate more, focus our mind, and put our heart and soul into every single movement. To do something with total commitment and dedication is deemed a great virtue in Japan. This pertains to minor tasks like sweeping a garden or cleaning the floor of the dojo - you ought to give it your full attention.
So, the Japanese instructors might have meant the mental aspect of “kime”, while we Westerners misunderstood it in the way that we should display physical power and strength.
From the Chinese perspective, ki can flow best, when one is totally relaxed. As a Karateka of a certain age, what happens after the technical kime, is much more interesting and important for the physique than what happens during tension. The alternation between tension and relaxation characterises the physical discipline of Karate. Now when we put the focus (kime) more on the latter, it might be good for our health and well-being – and our performance of Karate too!
Dr. Wolfgang Herbert, Professor of Comparative Cultural Studies at the University of Tokushima, 5th Dan Shotokan Karate, practices Yang-style Taijiquan. He can be contacted via his Dojo-homepage: https://skiftokushima.wordpress.com